DDI Labs

People counting technologies

Camera vs LiDAR vs thermal people counting

Camera analytics, LiDAR and thermal sensors all count people, but they suit different spaces. Cameras fit doorways and defined zones and can reuse hardware you already own. LiDAR covers large open areas without a camera image. Thermal counts in darkness with the least detail.

How each technology counts

TechnologyHow it worksIn darknessWhat it capturesHardware
Camera analyticsAI on the camera detects people crossing a line or inside a zoneNeeds light or infrared illuminationA camera image; counting can run on the camera and send only countsA compatible camera, often one already installed
Overhead 3D sensorA stereo or time-of-flight sensor above the doorway measures depth to separate peopleDepends on the modelA depth view from aboveA dedicated unit at each entrance
LiDARLaser pulses build a 3D view of an area and track the shapes moving through itYesA point cloud, not a pictureA dedicated sensor and processing unit
ThermalDetects body heat against the backgroundYesA heat pattern with no recognisable featuresA dedicated sensor at each doorway or zone
Infrared beamCounts each time a beam across the doorway is brokenYesNothing but beam breaksA transmitter and receiver on the door frame

Where each one fits

SpaceUsual best fitWhy
Shop, office and facility entrancesCamera analytics or an overhead 3D sensorA defined doorway is the easiest place to count accurately, and direction matters
Sites already covered by compatible camerasCamera analyticsNo new device to buy, cable or mount
Large open areas such as concourses and plazasLiDAROne sensor covers a wide area with no doorway to count at
Spaces where a camera is not acceptableThermal or LiDARNeither produces a recognisable image
One door and a rough numberInfrared beamCheapest option, with the least detail

Counting people without cameras

You can count people without a camera using thermal sensors, LiDAR, infrared beams or estimates from Wi-Fi and Bluetooth signals. Thermal and LiDAR give real counts without a recognisable image. Beams are cheap but cannot separate people walking side by side. Wi-Fi and Bluetooth give an estimate of presence, not a count.

The trade-off is hardware. Each of these needs a dedicated device installed for counting alone. Where a compatible security camera already covers the doorway, counting on that camera adds no new device, and the analytics can run on the camera and send only counts.

Accuracy: what matters more than the technology

  • Mounting position. A sensor or camera that cannot see the full width of the doorway will miss people, whatever technology it uses.
  • Doorway width and crowding. Wide entrances and groups moving in both directions are the hardest conditions for every counter.
  • Lighting and environment. Cameras need usable light. Thermal sensors are affected by warm backgrounds.
  • Validation. Check counts against a manual count at your own entrances before you rely on them, and repeat the check after any change.

Where CountIQ fits

CountIQ uses camera analytics. Counting runs on compatible Axis cameras and the counts are sent to a cloud dashboard for occupancy, footfall trends, alerts and scheduled reports.

It is a good fit where Axis cameras already cover your entrances. It is not the right tool for an area with no Axis camera, or for a space where a camera is not acceptable. For those, look at thermal or LiDAR.

Common questions

Is LiDAR more accurate than camera people counting?

Not as a rule. Accuracy depends more on where the device is mounted and how crowded the space is than on the technology. LiDAR has the advantage in large open areas and in darkness. Cameras and overhead 3D sensors do well at defined doorways.

Can you count people without cameras?

Yes. Thermal sensors, LiDAR and infrared beams all count people without a camera image, and Wi-Fi or Bluetooth signals can estimate presence. Each needs dedicated hardware installed for counting.

What is the cheapest way to count people?

An infrared beam counter is the cheapest device, but it cannot separate people walking side by side and basic units cannot tell direction. If compatible cameras are already installed, counting on those cameras avoids buying counting hardware at all.

Do camera-based people counters record video?

Counting and recording are separate. Counting analytics run on the camera and produce numbers. Whether video is also recorded is a setting of your camera or video management system, not of the counting.

Which people counting technology is best for retail stores?

Most stores count at the entrance, where camera analytics or an overhead 3D sensor work well. If the store already has compatible cameras at its doors, camera analytics is usually the lower-cost route because there is no new hardware to install.

Get in Touch

Ready to Start Your Automation Journey?

Our team is ready to discuss how our AI solutions can address your specific business challenges.

Email

sales@ddilabs.ai

Location

Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane

Contact Us